14 original flavors

Our gooey flavor menu

Nostalgic classics and bold, modern twists — each one baked fresh and stuffed with love. New seasonal surprises drop all the time.

Timeless Chocolate Chip cookie

Timeless Chocolate Chip

The one that started it all — gooey center, buttery edges.

Build your box →
Naked Dough cookie

Naked Dough

All dough. No chips. For the purists among us.

Build your box →
Dubai Chocolate cookieStuffed

Dubai Chocolate

Pistachio & crispy kunafa stuffed and drizzled in chocolate.

Build your box →
Biscoff cookieStuffed

Biscoff

Stuffed with creamy Biscoff cookie butter.

Build your box →
Stuffed

Nutella

Molten hazelnut chocolate in every bite.

Build your box →
Ferrero Rocher cookieStuffed

Ferrero Rocher

Crunchy, nutty, chocolate-hazelnut decadence.

Build your box →
S'mores cookieStuffed

S'mores

Toasted marshmallow, graham & milk chocolate.

Build your box →
Stuffed

Cookie Monster

Blue-dough, cookie-loaded, unapologetically fun.

Build your box →
Birthday Cake cookie

Birthday Cake

Funfetti sprinkles and vanilla-frosting joy.

Build your box →
Oreo cookie

Oreo

Cookies-and-cream crunch in every bite.

Build your box →
Fruity Pebbles cookie

Fruity Pebbles

Crunchy, colorful & straight-up nostalgic.

Build your box →

Cinnamon Toast Crunch

Cinnamon-sugar swirl on a breakfast-cereal classic.

Build your box →

M&M's

Loaded with melt-in-your-mouth candy.

Build your box →

Reese's

Peanut butter cup chunks in every bite.

Build your box →
Fall & Halloween

Seasonal Flavors

Cozy flavors. Spooky treats. Fall just got a whole lot gooier.

Order Now
Halloween Cookie Monster

Halloween Cookie Monster

Stuffed with a whole Oreo cookie and topped with Oreo pieces, orange-and-black candies, and candy eyes.

Build your box →
Pumpkin Spice Coffee Cake

Pumpkin Spice Coffee Cake

A pumpkin spice cookie with coffee cake crumble and a sweet drizzle.

Build your box →
Halloween Bat Cookie

Halloween Bat Cookie

A chocolate cookie dressed up with an Oreo bat, creamy drizzle, and cookie crumbs.

Build your box →

Flavor of the Month

We rotate a special limited-edition flavor every month. Follow us on Instagram & TikTok @gooeygoodies_to see what’s baking right now.

Gluten-Free Available

Available upon request — because everyone deserves cookies. Just let us know when you order.

Made Fresh to Order

Every Gooey is baked when you order it. Please allow 1 day so it arrives fresh and, well… gooey.

Ready for cookies that feel like home?

Baked to order — please allow 1 day. Minimum 6 Gooeys for pick-up.

Place an Order Browse Flavors